{
 "study": "SGR-008",
 "census": {
  "kept": 2122337,
  "excluded": {
   "old_style_id": 414114,
   "outside_2015_01_to_2026_09": 588959,
   "under_50_words": 69619,
   "withdrawn": 46,
   "non_english": 9
  }
 },
 "h1_h3": {
  "rows_read": 2122337,
  "primary": {
   "old": {
    "BASE": 4.537,
    "Y2024": 11.851,
    "Y2026": 3.026,
    "diff_2024_minus_base": 7.314,
    "ci_2024_minus_base": [
     5.418,
     8.847
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_2024": -8.825,
    "ci_2026_minus_2024": [
     -11.026,
     -6.293
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_base": -1.511,
    "ci_2026_minus_base": [
     -2.081,
     -0.929
    ]
   },
   "new": {
    "BASE": 1.898,
    "Y2024": 3.305,
    "Y2026": 12.388,
    "diff_2024_minus_base": 1.407,
    "ci_2024_minus_base": [
     0.904,
     1.787
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_2024": 9.083,
    "ci_2026_minus_2024": [
     6.752,
     10.893
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_base": 10.49,
    "ci_2026_minus_base": [
     7.817,
     12.619
    ]
   },
   "control": {
    "BASE": 73.484,
    "Y2024": 74.877,
    "Y2026": 72.637,
    "diff_2024_minus_base": 1.393,
    "ci_2024_minus_base": [
     0.791,
     1.785
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_2024": -2.24,
    "ci_2026_minus_2024": [
     -3.744,
     -0.436
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_base": -0.847,
    "ci_2026_minus_base": [
     -2.498,
     0.796
    ]
   },
   "n": {
    "BASE": 446418,
    "Y2024": 233900,
    "Y2026": 262617
   },
   "H1": true,
   "new_by_group": {
    "cs": {
     "base": 2.455,
     "y2026": 18.699,
     "ratio": 7.62,
     "n_base": 153219,
     "n_2026": 127159
    },
    "econ": {
     "base": 1.382,
     "y2026": 9.766,
     "ratio": 7.06,
     "n_base": 2604,
     "n_2026": 1925
    },
    "eess": {
     "base": 1.684,
     "y2026": 9.562,
     "ratio": 5.68,
     "n_base": 22975,
     "n_2026": 9663
    },
    "math": {
     "base": 1.316,
     "y2026": 4.642,
     "ratio": 3.53,
     "n_base": 70198,
     "n_2026": 40327
    },
    "physics": {
     "base": 1.654,
     "y2026": 6.185,
     "ratio": 3.74,
     "n_base": 177521,
     "n_2026": 73643
    },
    "q-bio": {
     "base": 2.195,
     "y2026": 15.127,
     "ratio": 6.89,
     "n_base": 6013,
     "n_2026": 2122
    },
    "q-fin": {
     "base": 1.696,
     "y2026": 11.447,
     "ratio": 6.75,
     "n_base": 2182,
     "n_2026": 1092
    },
    "stat": {
     "base": 2.221,
     "y2026": 11.532,
     "ratio": 5.19,
     "n_base": 11706,
     "n_2026": 6686
    }
   },
   "H2_groups_ratio_ge_2": 8,
   "H2": true,
   "H3": true,
   "H3_crossover_half": "2025H2",
   "half_series": {
    "2015H1": {
     "n": 46641,
     "old": 1.917,
     "new": 1.439,
     "control": 65.97
    },
    "2015H2": {
     "n": 49951,
     "old": 1.836,
     "new": 1.481,
     "control": 66.97
    },
    "2016H1": {
     "n": 50876,
     "old": 2.115,
     "new": 1.525,
     "control": 67.454
    },
    "2016H2": {
     "n": 53286,
     "old": 2.278,
     "new": 1.614,
     "control": 68.352
    },
    "2017H1": {
     "n": 55086,
     "old": 2.431,
     "new": 1.556,
     "control": 68.673
    },
    "2017H2": {
     "n": 58996,
     "old": 2.671,
     "new": 1.539,
     "control": 69.818
    },
    "2018H1": {
     "n": 63194,
     "old": 2.954,
     "new": 1.622,
     "control": 70.23
    },
    "2018H2": {
     "n": 66939,
     "old": 3.17,
     "new": 1.628,
     "control": 70.603
    },
    "2019H1": {
     "n": 69338,
     "old": 3.409,
     "new": 1.722,
     "control": 71.493
    },
    "2019H2": {
     "n": 74637,
     "old": 3.698,
     "new": 1.809,
     "control": 71.913
    },
    "2020H1": {
     "n": 79248,
     "old": 3.76,
     "new": 1.779,
     "control": 72.531
    },
    "2020H2": {
     "n": 84339,
     "old": 4.285,
     "new": 1.865,
     "control": 73.277
    },
    "2021H1": {
     "n": 81057,
     "old": 4.605,
     "new": 1.968,
     "control": 73.395
    },
    "2021H2": {
     "n": 78905,
     "old": 4.626,
     "new": 1.9,
     "control": 73.948
    },
    "2022H1": {
     "n": 71029,
     "old": 4.923,
     "new": 2.002,
     "control": 73.906
    },
    "2022H2": {
     "n": 65929,
     "old": 5.304,
     "new": 1.926,
     "control": 74.168
    },
    "2023H1": {
     "n": 95256,
     "old": 6.279,
     "new": 2.214,
     "control": 75.081
    },
    "2023H2": {
     "n": 103581,
     "old": 9.76,
     "new": 2.585,
     "control": 74.732
    },
    "2024H1": {
     "n": 113840,
     "old": 12.103,
     "new": 3.101,
     "control": 74.196
    },
    "2024H2": {
     "n": 120060,
     "old": 11.612,
     "new": 3.498,
     "control": 75.522
    },
    "2025H1": {
     "n": 130729,
     "old": 9.799,
     "new": 5.371,
     "control": 75.895
    },
    "2025H2": {
     "n": 143197,
     "old": 6.341,
     "new": 7.756,
     "control": 75.269
    },
    "2026H1": {
     "n": 164421,
     "old": 3.617,
     "new": 11.868,
     "control": 73.968
    },
    "2026H2": {
     "n": 98196,
     "old": 2.038,
     "new": 13.258,
     "control": 70.409
    }
   },
   "word_share_by_year": {
    "2015": {
     "innovative": 0.167,
     "utilized": 0.433,
     "advancements": 0.067,
     "pivotal": 0.086,
     "facilitates": 0.243,
     "firstly": 0.409,
     "tackle": 0.324,
     "showcasing": 0.008,
     "underscores": 0.019,
     "delve": 0.007,
     "delves": 0.001,
     "intricate": 0.139,
     "underexplored": 0.004,
     "grounded": 0.069,
     "aligns": 0.029,
     "synthesizes": 0.012,
     "replaces": 0.072,
     "leaving": 0.219,
     "recovers": 0.192,
     "expose": 0.074,
     "structurally": 0.117,
     "reproducible": 0.081,
     "treats": 0.133,
     "vanishes": 0.468,
     "however": 9.808,
     "results": 26.999,
     "using": 24.85,
     "show": 28.611,
     "method": 13.367
    },
    "2016": {
     "innovative": 0.195,
     "utilized": 0.554,
     "advancements": 0.062,
     "pivotal": 0.099,
     "facilitates": 0.256,
     "firstly": 0.481,
     "tackle": 0.394,
     "showcasing": 0.012,
     "underscores": 0.012,
     "delve": 0.011,
     "delves": 0.001,
     "intricate": 0.167,
     "underexplored": 0.007,
     "grounded": 0.072,
     "aligns": 0.036,
     "synthesizes": 0.023,
     "replaces": 0.098,
     "leaving": 0.238,
     "recovers": 0.225,
     "expose": 0.097,
     "structurally": 0.1,
     "reproducible": 0.094,
     "treats": 0.12,
     "vanishes": 0.478,
     "however": 10.622,
     "results": 27.89,
     "using": 25.634,
     "show": 29.313,
     "method": 14.242
    },
    "2017": {
     "innovative": 0.209,
     "utilized": 0.589,
     "advancements": 0.109,
     "pivotal": 0.088,
     "facilitates": 0.294,
     "firstly": 0.578,
     "tackle": 0.565,
     "showcasing": 0.016,
     "underscores": 0.011,
     "delve": 0.008,
     "delves": 0.004,
     "intricate": 0.143,
     "underexplored": 0.005,
     "grounded": 0.096,
     "aligns": 0.044,
     "synthesizes": 0.039,
     "replaces": 0.077,
     "leaving": 0.22,
     "recovers": 0.231,
     "expose": 0.096,
     "structurally": 0.119,
     "reproducible": 0.114,
     "treats": 0.11,
     "vanishes": 0.409,
     "however": 11.784,
     "results": 28.45,
     "using": 26.672,
     "show": 29.738,
     "method": 15.265
    },
    "2018": {
     "innovative": 0.257,
     "utilized": 0.721,
     "advancements": 0.124,
     "pivotal": 0.134,
     "facilitates": 0.343,
     "firstly": 0.596,
     "tackle": 0.738,
     "showcasing": 0.021,
     "underscores": 0.012,
     "delve": 0.014,
     "delves": 0.003,
     "intricate": 0.176,
     "underexplored": 0.015,
     "grounded": 0.135,
     "aligns": 0.05,
     "synthesizes": 0.043,
     "replaces": 0.095,
     "leaving": 0.237,
     "recovers": 0.227,
     "expose": 0.099,
     "structurally": 0.106,
     "reproducible": 0.122,
     "treats": 0.141,
     "vanishes": 0.37,
     "however": 13.08,
     "results": 29.293,
     "using": 27.248,
     "show": 30.356,
     "method": 16.499
    },
    "2019": {
     "innovative": 0.283,
     "utilized": 0.829,
     "advancements": 0.192,
     "pivotal": 0.117,
     "facilitates": 0.363,
     "firstly": 0.67,
     "tackle": 0.971,
     "showcasing": 0.026,
     "underscores": 0.02,
     "delve": 0.013,
     "delves": 0.001,
     "intricate": 0.179,
     "underexplored": 0.017,
     "grounded": 0.153,
     "aligns": 0.066,
     "synthesizes": 0.044,
     "replaces": 0.103,
     "leaving": 0.254,
     "recovers": 0.238,
     "expose": 0.129,
     "structurally": 0.115,
     "reproducible": 0.163,
     "treats": 0.133,
     "vanishes": 0.369,
     "however": 14.914,
     "results": 29.595,
     "using": 27.774,
     "show": 30.559,
     "method": 17.935
    },
    "2020": {
     "innovative": 0.306,
     "utilized": 0.937,
     "advancements": 0.222,
     "pivotal": 0.131,
     "facilitates": 0.442,
     "firstly": 0.72,
     "tackle": 1.122,
     "showcasing": 0.042,
     "underscores": 0.014,
     "delve": 0.018,
     "delves": 0.011,
     "intricate": 0.184,
     "underexplored": 0.024,
     "grounded": 0.188,
     "aligns": 0.073,
     "synthesizes": 0.061,
     "replaces": 0.107,
     "leaving": 0.244,
     "recovers": 0.26,
     "expose": 0.127,
     "structurally": 0.142,
     "reproducible": 0.195,
     "treats": 0.122,
     "vanishes": 0.301,
     "however": 16.512,
     "results": 30.776,
     "using": 28.533,
     "show": 30.787,
     "method": 18.699
    },
    "2021": {
     "innovative": 0.376,
     "utilized": 1.035,
     "advancements": 0.289,
     "pivotal": 0.176,
     "facilitates": 0.517,
     "firstly": 0.753,
     "tackle": 1.347,
     "showcasing": 0.05,
     "underscores": 0.02,
     "delve": 0.036,
     "delves": 0.008,
     "intricate": 0.196,
     "underexplored": 0.04,
     "grounded": 0.227,
     "aligns": 0.101,
     "synthesizes": 0.079,
     "replaces": 0.112,
     "leaving": 0.254,
     "recovers": 0.24,
     "expose": 0.149,
     "structurally": 0.13,
     "reproducible": 0.191,
     "treats": 0.131,
     "vanishes": 0.302,
     "however": 18.14,
     "results": 30.923,
     "using": 29.009,
     "show": 30.312,
     "method": 19.47
    },
    "2022": {
     "innovative": 0.395,
     "utilized": 1.103,
     "advancements": 0.34,
     "pivotal": 0.218,
     "facilitates": 0.472,
     "firstly": 0.89,
     "tackle": 1.546,
     "showcasing": 0.053,
     "underscores": 0.026,
     "delve": 0.04,
     "delves": 0.009,
     "intricate": 0.215,
     "underexplored": 0.083,
     "grounded": 0.221,
     "aligns": 0.136,
     "synthesizes": 0.071,
     "replaces": 0.125,
     "leaving": 0.269,
     "recovers": 0.211,
     "expose": 0.14,
     "structurally": 0.119,
     "reproducible": 0.207,
     "treats": 0.123,
     "vanishes": 0.283,
     "however": 20.078,
     "results": 30.998,
     "using": 29.055,
     "show": 29.751,
     "method": 20.375
    },
    "2023": {
     "innovative": 0.941,
     "utilized": 1.289,
     "advancements": 1.109,
     "pivotal": 0.579,
     "facilitates": 0.771,
     "firstly": 0.859,
     "tackle": 1.785,
     "showcasing": 0.306,
     "underscores": 0.265,
     "delve": 0.244,
     "delves": 0.225,
     "intricate": 0.747,
     "underexplored": 0.143,
     "grounded": 0.347,
     "aligns": 0.301,
     "synthesizes": 0.094,
     "replaces": 0.116,
     "leaving": 0.295,
     "recovers": 0.277,
     "expose": 0.127,
     "structurally": 0.121,
     "reproducible": 0.208,
     "treats": 0.155,
     "vanishes": 0.261,
     "however": 22.11,
     "results": 31.296,
     "using": 29.294,
     "show": 28.024,
     "method": 21.049
    },
    "2024": {
     "innovative": 1.702,
     "utilized": 1.413,
     "advancements": 2.457,
     "pivotal": 1.094,
     "facilitates": 1.159,
     "firstly": 0.82,
     "tackle": 1.848,
     "showcasing": 0.75,
     "underscores": 0.631,
     "delve": 0.352,
     "delves": 0.338,
     "intricate": 1.214,
     "underexplored": 0.426,
     "grounded": 0.503,
     "aligns": 0.631,
     "synthesizes": 0.118,
     "replaces": 0.139,
     "leaving": 0.371,
     "recovers": 0.262,
     "expose": 0.162,
     "structurally": 0.14,
     "reproducible": 0.222,
     "treats": 0.169,
     "vanishes": 0.246,
     "however": 23.558,
     "results": 31.077,
     "using": 29.921,
     "show": 24.723,
     "method": 21.665
    },
    "2025": {
     "innovative": 0.996,
     "utilized": 0.837,
     "advancements": 1.776,
     "pivotal": 0.69,
     "facilitates": 0.972,
     "firstly": 0.451,
     "tackle": 1.232,
     "showcasing": 0.43,
     "underscores": 0.486,
     "delve": 0.086,
     "delves": 0.067,
     "intricate": 0.786,
     "underexplored": 1.079,
     "grounded": 1.401,
     "aligns": 0.919,
     "synthesizes": 0.313,
     "replaces": 0.304,
     "leaving": 0.626,
     "recovers": 0.463,
     "expose": 0.33,
     "structurally": 0.348,
     "reproducible": 0.656,
     "treats": 0.33,
     "vanishes": 0.29,
     "however": 22.846,
     "results": 32.764,
     "using": 30.83,
     "show": 25.295,
     "method": 20.086
    },
    "2026": {
     "innovative": 0.227,
     "utilized": 0.355,
     "advancements": 0.389,
     "pivotal": 0.347,
     "facilitates": 0.478,
     "firstly": 0.206,
     "tackle": 0.577,
     "showcasing": 0.115,
     "underscores": 0.129,
     "delve": 0.022,
     "delves": 0.011,
     "intricate": 0.332,
     "underexplored": 0.996,
     "grounded": 2.435,
     "aligns": 0.952,
     "synthesizes": 0.442,
     "replaces": 0.804,
     "leaving": 1.708,
     "recovers": 1.725,
     "expose": 0.849,
     "structurally": 0.934,
     "reproducible": 1.348,
     "treats": 0.919,
     "vanishes": 0.581,
     "however": 18.102,
     "results": 31.344,
     "using": 28.537,
     "show": 30.188,
     "method": 14.616
    },
    "BASE": {
     "innovative": 0.355,
     "utilized": 1.018,
     "advancements": 0.277,
     "pivotal": 0.171,
     "facilitates": 0.475,
     "firstly": 0.782,
     "tackle": 1.32,
     "showcasing": 0.048,
     "underscores": 0.019,
     "delve": 0.03,
     "delves": 0.009,
     "intricate": 0.196,
     "underexplored": 0.045,
     "grounded": 0.211,
     "aligns": 0.1,
     "synthesizes": 0.072,
     "replaces": 0.114,
     "leaving": 0.252,
     "recovers": 0.238,
     "expose": 0.138,
     "structurally": 0.131,
     "reproducible": 0.198,
     "treats": 0.125,
     "vanishes": 0.296,
     "however": 18.108,
     "results": 30.899,
     "using": 28.847,
     "show": 30.318,
     "method": 19.451
    }
   }
  },
  "all_papers_sensitivity": {
   "old": {
    "BASE": 4.521,
    "Y2024": 11.851,
    "Y2026": 3.026,
    "diff_2024_minus_base": 7.33,
    "ci_2024_minus_base": [
     5.372,
     8.857
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_2024": -8.825,
    "ci_2026_minus_2024": [
     -10.914,
     -6.374
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_base": -1.495,
    "ci_2026_minus_base": [
     -2.098,
     -0.885
    ]
   },
   "new": {
    "BASE": 1.94,
    "Y2024": 3.305,
    "Y2026": 12.388,
    "diff_2024_minus_base": 1.365,
    "ci_2024_minus_base": [
     0.856,
     1.735
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_2024": 9.083,
    "ci_2026_minus_2024": [
     6.877,
     10.942
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_base": 10.448,
    "ci_2026_minus_base": [
     7.792,
     12.565
    ]
   },
   "control": {
    "BASE": 73.493,
    "Y2024": 74.877,
    "Y2026": 72.637,
    "diff_2024_minus_base": 1.384,
    "ci_2024_minus_base": [
     0.787,
     1.812
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_2024": -2.24,
    "ci_2026_minus_2024": [
     -3.818,
     -0.499
    ],
    "diff_2026_minus_base": -0.856,
    "ci_2026_minus_base": [
     -2.572,
     0.838
    ]
   },
   "n": {
    "BASE": 502852,
    "Y2024": 233900,
    "Y2026": 262617
   },
   "H1": true,
   "new_by_group": {
    "cs": {
     "base": 2.518,
     "y2026": 18.699,
     "ratio": 7.43,
     "n_base": 169795,
     "n_2026": 127159
    },
    "econ": {
     "base": 1.599,
     "y2026": 9.766,
     "ratio": 6.11,
     "n_base": 3378,
     "n_2026": 1925
    },
    "eess": {
     "base": 1.705,
     "y2026": 9.562,
     "ratio": 5.61,
     "n_base": 24868,
     "n_2026": 9663
    },
    "math": {
     "base": 1.382,
     "y2026": 4.642,
     "ratio": 3.36,
     "n_base": 86775,
     "n_2026": 40327
    },
    "physics": {
     "base": 1.678,
     "y2026": 6.185,
     "ratio": 3.69,
     "n_base": 194811,
     "n_2026": 73643
    },
    "q-bio": {
     "base": 2.315,
     "y2026": 15.127,
     "ratio": 6.53,
     "n_base": 6479,
     "n_2026": 2122
    },
    "q-fin": {
     "base": 1.709,
     "y2026": 11.447,
     "ratio": 6.7,
     "n_base": 2516,
     "n_2026": 1092
    },
    "stat": {
     "base": 2.41,
     "y2026": 11.532,
     "ratio": 4.78,
     "n_base": 14230,
     "n_2026": 6686
    }
   },
   "H2_groups_ratio_ge_2": 8,
   "H2": true,
   "H3": true,
   "H3_crossover_half": "2025H2",
   "half_series": {
    "2015H1": {
     "n": 46754,
     "old": 1.921,
     "new": 1.435,
     "control": 65.949
    },
    "2015H2": {
     "n": 50108,
     "old": 1.832,
     "new": 1.483,
     "control": 66.975
    },
    "2016H1": {
     "n": 51082,
     "old": 2.112,
     "new": 1.519,
     "control": 67.452
    },
    "2016H2": {
     "n": 53523,
     "old": 2.278,
     "new": 1.618,
     "control": 68.333
    },
    "2017H1": {
     "n": 55365,
     "old": 2.429,
     "new": 1.553,
     "control": 68.655
    },
    "2017H2": {
     "n": 59410,
     "old": 2.675,
     "new": 1.538,
     "control": 69.805
    },
    "2018H1": {
     "n": 63711,
     "old": 2.949,
     "new": 1.626,
     "control": 70.167
    },
    "2018H2": {
     "n": 67621,
     "old": 3.156,
     "new": 1.63,
     "control": 70.518
    },
    "2019H1": {
     "n": 70271,
     "old": 3.398,
     "new": 1.733,
     "control": 71.449
    },
    "2019H2": {
     "n": 75982,
     "old": 3.681,
     "new": 1.821,
     "control": 71.837
    },
    "2020H1": {
     "n": 81082,
     "old": 3.746,
     "new": 1.785,
     "control": 72.459
    },
    "2020H2": {
     "n": 87405,
     "old": 4.259,
     "new": 1.868,
     "control": 73.225
    },
    "2021H1": {
     "n": 85560,
     "old": 4.579,
     "new": 1.971,
     "control": 73.338
    },
    "2021H2": {
     "n": 86753,
     "old": 4.57,
     "new": 1.915,
     "control": 73.878
    },
    "2022H1": {
     "n": 85890,
     "old": 4.839,
     "new": 2.067,
     "control": 73.89
    },
    "2022H2": {
     "n": 90251,
     "old": 5.155,
     "new": 2.049,
     "control": 74.205
    },
    "2023H1": {
     "n": 95256,
     "old": 6.279,
     "new": 2.214,
     "control": 75.081
    },
    "2023H2": {
     "n": 103581,
     "old": 9.76,
     "new": 2.585,
     "control": 74.732
    },
    "2024H1": {
     "n": 113840,
     "old": 12.103,
     "new": 3.101,
     "control": 74.196
    },
    "2024H2": {
     "n": 120060,
     "old": 11.612,
     "new": 3.498,
     "control": 75.522
    },
    "2025H1": {
     "n": 130729,
     "old": 9.799,
     "new": 5.371,
     "control": 75.895
    },
    "2025H2": {
     "n": 143197,
     "old": 6.341,
     "new": 7.756,
     "control": 75.269
    },
    "2026H1": {
     "n": 164421,
     "old": 3.617,
     "new": 11.868,
     "control": 73.968
    },
    "2026H2": {
     "n": 98196,
     "old": 2.038,
     "new": 13.258,
     "control": 70.409
    }
   },
   "word_share_by_year": {
    "2015": {
     "innovative": 0.166,
     "utilized": 0.435,
     "advancements": 0.067,
     "pivotal": 0.086,
     "facilitates": 0.243,
     "firstly": 0.409,
     "tackle": 0.323,
     "showcasing": 0.008,
     "underscores": 0.019,
     "delve": 0.007,
     "delves": 0.002,
     "intricate": 0.138,
     "underexplored": 0.004,
     "grounded": 0.069,
     "aligns": 0.029,
     "synthesizes": 0.012,
     "replaces": 0.073,
     "leaving": 0.219,
     "recovers": 0.192,
     "expose": 0.073,
     "structurally": 0.117,
     "reproducible": 0.081,
     "treats": 0.132,
     "vanishes": 0.468,
     "however": 9.806,
     "results": 27.001,
     "using": 24.842,
     "show": 28.612,
     "method": 13.358
    },
    "2016": {
     "innovative": 0.195,
     "utilized": 0.553,
     "advancements": 0.064,
     "pivotal": 0.098,
     "facilitates": 0.256,
     "firstly": 0.48,
     "tackle": 0.392,
     "showcasing": 0.011,
     "underscores": 0.011,
     "delve": 0.011,
     "delves": 0.001,
     "intricate": 0.168,
     "underexplored": 0.007,
     "grounded": 0.072,
     "aligns": 0.036,
     "synthesizes": 0.024,
     "replaces": 0.098,
     "leaving": 0.238,
     "recovers": 0.225,
     "expose": 0.097,
     "structurally": 0.099,
     "reproducible": 0.094,
     "treats": 0.119,
     "vanishes": 0.478,
     "however": 10.617,
     "results": 27.872,
     "using": 25.616,
     "show": 29.312,
     "method": 14.238
    },
    "2017": {
     "innovative": 0.209,
     "utilized": 0.589,
     "advancements": 0.109,
     "pivotal": 0.088,
     "facilitates": 0.294,
     "firstly": 0.58,
     "tackle": 0.562,
     "showcasing": 0.016,
     "underscores": 0.01,
     "delve": 0.009,
     "delves": 0.003,
     "intricate": 0.143,
     "underexplored": 0.005,
     "grounded": 0.096,
     "aligns": 0.044,
     "synthesizes": 0.038,
     "replaces": 0.077,
     "leaving": 0.221,
     "recovers": 0.232,
     "expose": 0.097,
     "structurally": 0.118,
     "reproducible": 0.115,
     "treats": 0.109,
     "vanishes": 0.408,
     "however": 11.764,
     "results": 28.424,
     "using": 26.654,
     "show": 29.759,
     "method": 15.253
    },
    "2018": {
     "innovative": 0.255,
     "utilized": 0.717,
     "advancements": 0.124,
     "pivotal": 0.133,
     "facilitates": 0.343,
     "firstly": 0.594,
     "tackle": 0.735,
     "showcasing": 0.021,
     "underscores": 0.012,
     "delve": 0.014,
     "delves": 0.003,
     "intricate": 0.177,
     "underexplored": 0.015,
     "grounded": 0.135,
     "aligns": 0.05,
     "synthesizes": 0.043,
     "replaces": 0.097,
     "leaving": 0.239,
     "recovers": 0.23,
     "expose": 0.099,
     "structurally": 0.105,
     "reproducible": 0.122,
     "treats": 0.142,
     "vanishes": 0.369,
     "however": 13.047,
     "results": 29.252,
     "using": 27.188,
     "show": 30.338,
     "method": 16.47
    },
    "2019": {
     "innovative": 0.285,
     "utilized": 0.824,
     "advancements": 0.189,
     "pivotal": 0.118,
     "facilitates": 0.362,
     "firstly": 0.669,
     "tackle": 0.965,
     "showcasing": 0.025,
     "underscores": 0.02,
     "delve": 0.012,
     "delves": 0.001,
     "intricate": 0.179,
     "underexplored": 0.018,
     "grounded": 0.152,
     "aligns": 0.067,
     "synthesizes": 0.044,
     "replaces": 0.108,
     "leaving": 0.253,
     "recovers": 0.245,
     "expose": 0.129,
     "structurally": 0.116,
     "reproducible": 0.163,
     "treats": 0.133,
     "vanishes": 0.369,
     "however": 14.837,
     "results": 29.556,
     "using": 27.686,
     "show": 30.587,
     "method": 17.887
    },
    "2020": {
     "innovative": 0.301,
     "utilized": 0.934,
     "advancements": 0.217,
     "pivotal": 0.131,
     "facilitates": 0.442,
     "firstly": 0.718,
     "tackle": 1.113,
     "showcasing": 0.044,
     "underscores": 0.016,
     "delve": 0.02,
     "delves": 0.012,
     "intricate": 0.185,
     "underexplored": 0.024,
     "grounded": 0.186,
     "aligns": 0.075,
     "synthesizes": 0.06,
     "replaces": 0.106,
     "leaving": 0.244,
     "recovers": 0.272,
     "expose": 0.127,
     "structurally": 0.141,
     "reproducible": 0.193,
     "treats": 0.12,
     "vanishes": 0.3,
     "however": 16.361,
     "results": 30.73,
     "using": 28.371,
     "show": 30.901,
     "method": 18.631
    },
    "2021": {
     "innovative": 0.372,
     "utilized": 1.012,
     "advancements": 0.29,
     "pivotal": 0.182,
     "facilitates": 0.515,
     "firstly": 0.75,
     "tackle": 1.329,
     "showcasing": 0.056,
     "underscores": 0.019,
     "delve": 0.037,
     "delves": 0.008,
     "intricate": 0.193,
     "underexplored": 0.043,
     "grounded": 0.224,
     "aligns": 0.104,
     "synthesizes": 0.077,
     "replaces": 0.117,
     "leaving": 0.248,
     "recovers": 0.258,
     "expose": 0.144,
     "structurally": 0.128,
     "reproducible": 0.19,
     "treats": 0.128,
     "vanishes": 0.304,
     "however": 17.875,
     "results": 30.835,
     "using": 28.7,
     "show": 30.659,
     "method": 19.379
    },
    "2022": {
     "innovative": 0.376,
     "utilized": 1.032,
     "advancements": 0.34,
     "pivotal": 0.218,
     "facilitates": 0.476,
     "firstly": 0.853,
     "tackle": 1.517,
     "showcasing": 0.066,
     "underscores": 0.033,
     "delve": 0.047,
     "delves": 0.018,
     "intricate": 0.244,
     "underexplored": 0.079,
     "grounded": 0.233,
     "aligns": 0.141,
     "synthesizes": 0.074,
     "replaces": 0.132,
     "leaving": 0.262,
     "recovers": 0.266,
     "expose": 0.141,
     "structurally": 0.118,
     "reproducible": 0.197,
     "treats": 0.136,
     "vanishes": 0.305,
     "however": 19.544,
     "results": 30.674,
     "using": 28.633,
     "show": 30.713,
     "method": 20.219
    },
    "2023": {
     "innovative": 0.941,
     "utilized": 1.289,
     "advancements": 1.109,
     "pivotal": 0.579,
     "facilitates": 0.771,
     "firstly": 0.859,
     "tackle": 1.785,
     "showcasing": 0.306,
     "underscores": 0.265,
     "delve": 0.244,
     "delves": 0.225,
     "intricate": 0.747,
     "underexplored": 0.143,
     "grounded": 0.347,
     "aligns": 0.301,
     "synthesizes": 0.094,
     "replaces": 0.116,
     "leaving": 0.295,
     "recovers": 0.277,
     "expose": 0.127,
     "structurally": 0.121,
     "reproducible": 0.208,
     "treats": 0.155,
     "vanishes": 0.261,
     "however": 22.11,
     "results": 31.296,
     "using": 29.294,
     "show": 28.024,
     "method": 21.049
    },
    "2024": {
     "innovative": 1.702,
     "utilized": 1.413,
     "advancements": 2.457,
     "pivotal": 1.094,
     "facilitates": 1.159,
     "firstly": 0.82,
     "tackle": 1.848,
     "showcasing": 0.75,
     "underscores": 0.631,
     "delve": 0.352,
     "delves": 0.338,
     "intricate": 1.214,
     "underexplored": 0.426,
     "grounded": 0.503,
     "aligns": 0.631,
     "synthesizes": 0.118,
     "replaces": 0.139,
     "leaving": 0.371,
     "recovers": 0.262,
     "expose": 0.162,
     "structurally": 0.14,
     "reproducible": 0.222,
     "treats": 0.169,
     "vanishes": 0.246,
     "however": 23.558,
     "results": 31.077,
     "using": 29.921,
     "show": 24.723,
     "method": 21.665
    },
    "2025": {
     "innovative": 0.996,
     "utilized": 0.837,
     "advancements": 1.776,
     "pivotal": 0.69,
     "facilitates": 0.972,
     "firstly": 0.451,
     "tackle": 1.232,
     "showcasing": 0.43,
     "underscores": 0.486,
     "delve": 0.086,
     "delves": 0.067,
     "intricate": 0.786,
     "underexplored": 1.079,
     "grounded": 1.401,
     "aligns": 0.919,
     "synthesizes": 0.313,
     "replaces": 0.304,
     "leaving": 0.626,
     "recovers": 0.463,
     "expose": 0.33,
     "structurally": 0.348,
     "reproducible": 0.656,
     "treats": 0.33,
     "vanishes": 0.29,
     "however": 22.846,
     "results": 32.764,
     "using": 30.83,
     "show": 25.295,
     "method": 20.086
    },
    "2026": {
     "innovative": 0.227,
     "utilized": 0.355,
     "advancements": 0.389,
     "pivotal": 0.347,
     "facilitates": 0.478,
     "firstly": 0.206,
     "tackle": 0.577,
     "showcasing": 0.115,
     "underscores": 0.129,
     "delve": 0.022,
     "delves": 0.011,
     "intricate": 0.332,
     "underexplored": 0.996,
     "grounded": 2.435,
     "aligns": 0.952,
     "synthesizes": 0.442,
     "replaces": 0.804,
     "leaving": 1.708,
     "recovers": 1.725,
     "expose": 0.849,
     "structurally": 0.934,
     "reproducible": 1.348,
     "treats": 0.919,
     "vanishes": 0.581,
     "however": 18.102,
     "results": 31.344,
     "using": 28.537,
     "show": 30.188,
     "method": 14.616
    },
    "BASE": {
     "innovative": 0.349,
     "utilized": 0.99,
     "advancements": 0.281,
     "pivotal": 0.176,
     "facilitates": 0.477,
     "firstly": 0.774,
     "tackle": 1.317,
     "showcasing": 0.056,
     "underscores": 0.022,
     "delve": 0.034,
     "delves": 0.013,
     "intricate": 0.207,
     "underexplored": 0.048,
     "grounded": 0.215,
     "aligns": 0.106,
     "synthesizes": 0.072,
     "replaces": 0.118,
     "leaving": 0.249,
     "recovers": 0.265,
     "expose": 0.137,
     "structurally": 0.129,
     "reproducible": 0.194,
     "treats": 0.128,
     "vanishes": 0.303,
     "however": 17.918,
     "results": 30.747,
     "using": 28.557,
     "show": 30.773,
     "method": 19.407
    }
   }
  },
  "latest_version_lag_days_median": {
   "2024": 0,
   "2025": 0,
   "2026": 0
  },
  "share_revised_after_90_days": {
   "2024": 30.96,
   "2025": 26.7,
   "2026": 7.58
  }
 },
 "h5_and_bounds": {
  "style_2024": [
   "challenges",
   "additionally",
   "findings",
   "enhance",
   "insights",
   "crucial",
   "comprehensive",
   "enhancing",
   "capabilities",
   "introduces",
   "effectively",
   "particularly",
   "diverse",
   "leveraging",
   "enabling",
   "challenge",
   "enhances",
   "offering",
   "traditional",
   "thereby",
   "remains",
   "providing",
   "limitations",
   "advancements",
   "like",
   "achieving",
   "offers",
   "critical",
   "utilizing",
   "addressing",
   "designed",
   "leading",
   "practical",
   "integrating",
   "notably",
   "ensuring",
   "distinct",
   "exhibit",
   "employing",
   "presents",
   "substantial",
   "demonstrates",
   "tailored",
   "leverages",
   "explore",
   "valuable",
   "integrates",
   "employs",
   "highlighting",
   "innovative"
  ],
  "style_2026": [
   "remains",
   "yet",
   "rather",
   "establish",
   "explicit",
   "enabling",
   "every",
   "remain",
   "fixed",
   "yields",
   "improves",
   "practical",
   "structured",
   "findings",
   "consistently",
   "substantially",
   "structural",
   "whether",
   "reduces",
   "enables",
   "resulting",
   "support",
   "evidence",
   "consistent",
   "distinct",
   "toward",
   "controlled",
   "increasingly",
   "rely",
   "together",
   "beyond",
   "constraints",
   "gap",
   "whose",
   "unified",
   "exact",
   "preserving",
   "gains",
   "whereas",
   "combines",
   "spanning",
   "behavior",
   "relative",
   "against",
   "complementary",
   "foundation",
   "alone",
   "critical",
   "settings",
   "requires"
  ],
  "H5": {
   "jaccard": 0.064,
   "supported": true,
   "overlap": [
    "critical",
    "distinct",
    "enabling",
    "findings",
    "practical",
    "remains"
   ]
  },
  "bounds": {
   "set2024": {
    "2023": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 12.74,
     "ci95": [
      7.62,
      17.28
     ]
    },
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 29.19,
     "ci95": [
      20.33,
      36.88
     ]
    },
    "2025": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 39.89,
     "ci95": [
      31.21,
      47.39
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 20.36,
     "ci95": [
      13.14,
      26.43
     ]
    }
   },
   "set2026": {
    "2023": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 12.25,
     "ci95": [
      9.31,
      14.36
     ]
    },
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 23.07,
     "ci95": [
      17.82,
      26.54
     ]
    },
    "2025": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 47.96,
     "ci95": [
      41.14,
      52.54
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 68.39,
     "ci95": [
      61.71,
      72.86
     ]
    }
   },
   "union": {
    "2023": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 16.83,
     "ci95": [
      11.23,
      21.62
     ]
    },
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 32.77,
     "ci95": [
      24.58,
      40.16
     ]
    },
    "2025": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 51.02,
     "ci95": [
      42.89,
      57.92
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 63.8,
     "ci95": [
      56.11,
      69.54
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  "bounds_by_group_union": {
   "cs": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 53.54,
     "ci95": [
      38.51,
      61.55
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 80.26,
     "ci95": [
      67.43,
      85.98
     ]
    }
   },
   "econ": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": null,
     "ci95": [
      -481.37,
      9.63
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": null,
     "ci95": [
      -631.16,
      20.57
     ]
    }
   },
   "eess": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 45.55,
     "ci95": [
      29.63,
      57.44
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 70.91,
     "ci95": [
      39.44,
      83.98
     ]
    }
   },
   "math": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 14.44,
     "ci95": [
      6.56,
      19.57
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 48.91,
     "ci95": [
      38.83,
      53.64
     ]
    }
   },
   "physics": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 28.64,
     "ci95": [
      20.49,
      32.58
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 63.17,
     "ci95": [
      55.32,
      66.17
     ]
    }
   },
   "q-bio": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 10.71,
     "ci95": [
      -124.27,
      42.23
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 28.28,
     "ci95": [
      -795.95,
      82.33
     ]
    }
   },
   "q-fin": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 24.47,
     "ci95": [
      -608.2,
      66.67
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 27.18,
     "ci95": [
      -867.44,
      89.35
     ]
    }
   },
   "stat": {
    "2024": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 45.79,
     "ci95": [
      15.51,
      47.94
     ]
    },
    "2026": {
     "lower_bound_pct": 77.13,
     "ci95": [
      19.73,
      81.03
     ]
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "placebo": {
  "A_actual_sets": {
   "set2024": {
    "2018": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": 2.38,
     "ci95": [
      0.23,
      4.52
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2023"
    },
    "2019": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": 4.98,
     "ci95": [
      1.5,
      8.38
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2024"
    },
    "2020": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": 8.17,
     "ci95": [
      3.37,
      12.9
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2025"
    },
    "2021": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": 10.2,
     "ci95": [
      4.22,
      15.74
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2026"
    }
   },
   "set2026": {
    "2018": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": -0.22,
     "ci95": [
      -3.27,
      2.72
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2023"
    },
    "2019": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": -1.02,
     "ci95": [
      -6.06,
      3.65
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2024"
    },
    "2020": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": 0.68,
     "ci95": [
      -7.05,
      7.21
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2025"
    },
    "2021": {
     "placebo_bound_pct": 0.47,
     "ci95": [
      -9.44,
      9.74
     ],
     "real_year_equivalent": "2026"
    }
   }
  },
  "B_reselected_on_pre_llm_data": {
   "2019": {
    "words": [
     "accurate",
     "additional",
     "aims",
     "attack",
     "bert",
     "bias",
     "com",
     "control",
     "create",
     "crucial",
     "currently",
     "dataset",
     "detection",
     "devices",
     "environment",
     "environments",
     "especially",
     "evaluation",
     "extensive",
     "findings",
     "focus",
     "future",
     "generalization",
     "github",
     "https",
     "importance",
     "improve",
     "issues",
     "less",
     "machine",
     "mechanism",
     "need",
     "progress",
     "promising",
     "real-world",
     "research",
     "respectively",
     "signal",
     "simultaneously",
     "solve",
     "specific",
     "structures",
     "studies",
     "tasks",
     "test",
     "therefore",
     "towards",
     "understanding",
     "widely",
     "years"
    ],
    "placebo_bound_pct": 2.55,
    "ci95": [
     -4.35,
     8.66
    ],
    "real_year_equivalent": "2024"
   },
   "2021": {
    "words": [
     "accurate",
     "aims",
     "attention",
     "being",
     "bias",
     "challenges",
     "code",
     "com",
     "context",
     "contrastive",
     "covid-",
     "create",
     "crucial",
     "detection",
     "developed",
     "downstream",
     "especially",
     "essential",
     "evaluation",
     "extensive",
     "findings",
     "focus",
     "future",
     "gap",
     "generalization",
     "github",
     "global",
     "https",
     "importance",
     "issues",
     "lack",
     "mechanism",
     "need",
     "pandemic",
     "pre-trained",
     "predictions",
     "progress",
     "promising",
     "remains",
     "respectively",
     "self-supervised",
     "solve",
     "source",
     "test",
     "therefore",
     "towards",
     "transformer",
     "understanding",
     "widely",
     "years"
    ],
    "placebo_bound_pct": 10.07,
    "ci95": [
     -1.68,
     19.13
    ],
    "real_year_equivalent": "2026"
   }
  }
 },
 "instruments": {
  "periods": {
   "BASE": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.464,
    "sentence_length_variance": 79.791,
    "comma_density": 1.046,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.574,
    "pronoun_we": 0.982,
    "word_long": 0.286,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.309,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.022,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.332,
    "words": 161.797
   },
   "Y2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.103,
    "sentence_length_variance": 74.319,
    "comma_density": 1.189,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.49,
    "pronoun_we": 0.985,
    "word_long": 0.311,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.513,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.001,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.325,
    "words": 166.964
   },
   "Y2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.492,
    "sentence_length_variance": 77.807,
    "comma_density": 1.381,
    "semicolon_frequency": 1.053,
    "pronoun_we": 0.983,
    "word_long": 0.342,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.434,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.07,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.328,
    "words": 174.994
   }
  },
  "H4": {
   "diff_2026_minus_base": 0.028,
   "ci90": [
    -0.111,
    0.169
   ],
   "supported": true
  },
  "diffs_2026_minus_base_ci95": {
   "avg_sentence_length": {
    "diff": 0.028,
    "ci95": [
     -0.137,
     0.197
    ]
   },
   "sentence_length_variance": {
    "diff": -1.984,
    "ci95": [
     -4.288,
     0.023
    ]
   },
   "comma_density": {
    "diff": 0.335,
    "ci95": [
     0.281,
     0.374
    ]
   },
   "semicolon_frequency": {
    "diff": 0.479,
    "ci95": [
     0.374,
     0.579
    ]
   },
   "pronoun_we": {
    "diff": 0.001,
    "ci95": [
     -0.0,
     0.002
    ]
   },
   "word_long": {
    "diff": 0.056,
    "ci95": [
     0.048,
     0.063
    ]
   },
   "ai_tell_per1000": {
    "diff": 0.125,
    "ci95": [
     0.091,
     0.161
    ]
   },
   "em_dash_per1000": {
    "diff": 0.048,
    "ci95": [
     0.041,
     0.055
    ]
   },
   "burstiness_variation": {
    "diff": -0.004,
    "ci95": [
     -0.006,
     -0.001
    ]
   },
   "words": {
    "diff": 13.197,
    "ci95": [
     10.024,
     16.209
    ]
   }
  },
  "by_year": {
   "2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.768,
    "sentence_length_variance": 84.547,
    "comma_density": 0.945,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.593,
    "pronoun_we": 0.977,
    "word_long": 0.271,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.157,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.09,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.335,
    "words": 145.476
   },
   "2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.714,
    "sentence_length_variance": 83.632,
    "comma_density": 0.953,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.572,
    "pronoun_we": 0.978,
    "word_long": 0.273,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.18,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.102,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.334,
    "words": 147.957
   },
   "2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.67,
    "sentence_length_variance": 82.926,
    "comma_density": 0.97,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.568,
    "pronoun_we": 0.979,
    "word_long": 0.274,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.189,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.103,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.334,
    "words": 150.196
   },
   "2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.597,
    "sentence_length_variance": 81.338,
    "comma_density": 0.989,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.572,
    "pronoun_we": 0.981,
    "word_long": 0.278,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.228,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.113,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.332,
    "words": 153.048
   },
   "2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.532,
    "sentence_length_variance": 80.422,
    "comma_density": 1.006,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.594,
    "pronoun_we": 0.982,
    "word_long": 0.281,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.252,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.102,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.331,
    "words": 154.992
   },
   "2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.48,
    "sentence_length_variance": 80.06,
    "comma_density": 1.029,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.582,
    "pronoun_we": 0.982,
    "word_long": 0.284,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.273,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.057,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.332,
    "words": 159.788
   },
   "2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.484,
    "sentence_length_variance": 79.64,
    "comma_density": 1.049,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.564,
    "pronoun_we": 0.982,
    "word_long": 0.287,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.312,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.002,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.331,
    "words": 162.231
   },
   "2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.416,
    "sentence_length_variance": 79.511,
    "comma_density": 1.066,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.571,
    "pronoun_we": 0.981,
    "word_long": 0.288,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.351,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.332,
    "words": 163.717
   },
   "2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.288,
    "sentence_length_variance": 77.693,
    "comma_density": 1.115,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.529,
    "pronoun_we": 0.983,
    "word_long": 0.297,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.463,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.33,
    "words": 165.677
   },
   "2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.103,
    "sentence_length_variance": 74.319,
    "comma_density": 1.189,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.49,
    "pronoun_we": 0.985,
    "word_long": 0.311,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.513,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.001,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.325,
    "words": 166.964
   },
   "2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.164,
    "sentence_length_variance": 72.739,
    "comma_density": 1.307,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.62,
    "pronoun_we": 0.982,
    "word_long": 0.333,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.532,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.006,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.32,
    "words": 168.24
   },
   "2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.492,
    "sentence_length_variance": 77.807,
    "comma_density": 1.381,
    "semicolon_frequency": 1.053,
    "pronoun_we": 0.983,
    "word_long": 0.342,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.434,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.07,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.328,
    "words": 174.994
   },
   "BASE": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.464,
    "sentence_length_variance": 79.791,
    "comma_density": 1.046,
    "semicolon_frequency": 0.574,
    "pronoun_we": 0.982,
    "word_long": 0.286,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.309,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.022,
    "burstiness_variation": 0.332,
    "words": 161.797
   }
  },
  "by_group_year": {
   "cs:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.673,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.26,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.132,
    "words": 157.415
   },
   "cs:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.594,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.269,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.185,
    "words": 159.887
   },
   "cs:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.631,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.28,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.149,
    "words": 162.356
   },
   "cs:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.498,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.311,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.161,
    "words": 164.018
   },
   "cs:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.467,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.397,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.148,
    "words": 165.592
   },
   "cs:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.5,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.375,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.079,
    "words": 169.715
   },
   "cs:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.427,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.416,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.003,
    "words": 171.79
   },
   "cs:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.425,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.468,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 173.39
   },
   "cs:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.308,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.612,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 176.649
   },
   "cs:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.174,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.667,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.001,
    "words": 176.334
   },
   "cs:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.415,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.653,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.005,
    "words": 176.692
   },
   "cs:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.043,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.504,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.072,
    "words": 185.017
   },
   "econ:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.197,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 2.101,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.057,
    "words": 153.031
   },
   "econ:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.314,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.153,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 153.245
   },
   "econ:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.91,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.158,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.244,
    "words": 150.206
   },
   "econ:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.87,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.605,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.193,
    "words": 146.262
   },
   "econ:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.081,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.454,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.165,
    "words": 146.47
   },
   "econ:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.883,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.531,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.088,
    "words": 152.43
   },
   "econ:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.214,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.699,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 156.014
   },
   "econ:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.147,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.764,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 153.459
   },
   "econ:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.565,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.77,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.008,
    "words": 149.178
   },
   "econ:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.408,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.727,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.027,
    "words": 150.007
   },
   "econ:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.437,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.636,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.063,
    "words": 154.192
   },
   "econ:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 22.946,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.662,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.219,
    "words": 158.584
   },
   "eess:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.439,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.065,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.042,
    "words": 141.877
   },
   "eess:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.379,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.1,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.104,
    "words": 148.446
   },
   "eess:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.533,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.238,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.07,
    "words": 154.169
   },
   "eess:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.664,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.3,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.074,
    "words": 159.767
   },
   "eess:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.498,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.368,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.066,
    "words": 164.404
   },
   "eess:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.505,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.399,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.051,
    "words": 169.345
   },
   "eess:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.757,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.405,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 171.834
   },
   "eess:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.431,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.509,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 171.425
   },
   "eess:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.536,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.635,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 173.91
   },
   "eess:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.568,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.726,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 174.443
   },
   "eess:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.642,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.643,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.001,
    "words": 171.155
   },
   "eess:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.272,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.501,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.026,
    "words": 174.303
   },
   "math:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.502,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.197,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.071,
    "words": 113.866
   },
   "math:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.482,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.226,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.076,
    "words": 114.772
   },
   "math:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.604,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.23,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.074,
    "words": 116.381
   },
   "math:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.55,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.239,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.082,
    "words": 116.904
   },
   "math:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.519,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.237,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.053,
    "words": 117.912
   },
   "math:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.497,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.277,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.038,
    "words": 120.566
   },
   "math:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.655,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.325,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.002,
    "words": 121.816
   },
   "math:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.602,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.392,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 120.121
   },
   "math:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.673,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.417,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 123.728
   },
   "math:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.592,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.414,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 123.739
   },
   "math:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.671,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.514,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.006,
    "words": 126.519
   },
   "math:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.43,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.428,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.054,
    "words": 135.343
   },
   "physics:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.279,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.115,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.087,
    "words": 153.627
   },
   "physics:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.299,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.135,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.08,
    "words": 156.246
   },
   "physics:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.299,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.139,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.09,
    "words": 158.122
   },
   "physics:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.384,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.176,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.099,
    "words": 161.071
   },
   "physics:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.441,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.162,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.092,
    "words": 162.098
   },
   "physics:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.43,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.185,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.05,
    "words": 166.082
   },
   "physics:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.489,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.218,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.001,
    "words": 167.725
   },
   "physics:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.488,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.219,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 168.936
   },
   "physics:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.383,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.313,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 170.522
   },
   "physics:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.276,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.337,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.001,
    "words": 172.419
   },
   "physics:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.219,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.384,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.005,
    "words": 173.292
   },
   "physics:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 25.424,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.341,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.073,
    "words": 178.942
   },
   "q-bio:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.447,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.479,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.075,
    "words": 177.829
   },
   "q-bio:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.231,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.409,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.136,
    "words": 176.929
   },
   "q-bio:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.09,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.42,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.112,
    "words": 178.141
   },
   "q-bio:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.187,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.524,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.094,
    "words": 181.805
   },
   "q-bio:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.147,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.468,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.107,
    "words": 182.536
   },
   "q-bio:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.525,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.391,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.042,
    "words": 182.059
   },
   "q-bio:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.381,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.378,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.005,
    "words": 183.77
   },
   "q-bio:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.299,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.305,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 186.862
   },
   "q-bio:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.114,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.386,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 186.146
   },
   "q-bio:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.934,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.412,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 184.679
   },
   "q-bio:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.852,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.368,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.005,
    "words": 184.358
   },
   "q-bio:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.165,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.324,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.061,
    "words": 191.128
   },
   "q-fin:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.427,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.439,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.009,
    "words": 139.586
   },
   "q-fin:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.038,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.354,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.112,
    "words": 139.159
   },
   "q-fin:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.782,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.289,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.094,
    "words": 139.271
   },
   "q-fin:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.974,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.415,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.091,
    "words": 145.071
   },
   "q-fin:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.958,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.367,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.046,
    "words": 146.555
   },
   "q-fin:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.858,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.192,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 150.536
   },
   "q-fin:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.942,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.33,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 150.574
   },
   "q-fin:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.132,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.361,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 154.649
   },
   "q-fin:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.958,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.43,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 154.824
   },
   "q-fin:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.856,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.741,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 157.888
   },
   "q-fin:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.033,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.452,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.01,
    "words": 159.364
   },
   "q-fin:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.077,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.371,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.082,
    "words": 174.568
   },
   "stat:2015": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.185,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 0.844,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.119,
    "words": 156.97
   },
   "stat:2016": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.383,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 0.936,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.179,
    "words": 156.712
   },
   "stat:2017": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.311,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 0.964,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.179,
    "words": 159.651
   },
   "stat:2018": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.369,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.013,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.17,
    "words": 161.271
   },
   "stat:2019": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.459,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 0.961,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.157,
    "words": 163.732
   },
   "stat:2020": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.729,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.033,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.065,
    "words": 167.149
   },
   "stat:2021": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.671,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 0.993,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.005,
    "words": 168.306
   },
   "stat:2022": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.644,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.001,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 170.083
   },
   "stat:2023": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.736,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.154,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.0,
    "words": 170.461
   },
   "stat:2024": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.606,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.199,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.003,
    "words": 173.274
   },
   "stat:2025": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 23.56,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.081,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.013,
    "words": 172.532
   },
   "stat:2026": {
    "avg_sentence_length": 24.059,
    "ai_tell_per1000": 1.063,
    "em_dash_per1000": 0.097,
    "words": 180.722
   }
  }
 },
 "retro_polish": {
  "2015": {
   "n_revised": 270,
   "n_unrevised": 96592,
   "pct_revised": 0.28,
   "old_revised": 1.85,
   "old_unrevised": 1.87,
   "new_revised": 1.11,
   "new_unrevised": 1.46,
   "control_revised": 64.07,
   "control_unrevised": 66.49
  },
  "2016": {
   "n_revised": 443,
   "n_unrevised": 104162,
   "pct_revised": 0.42,
   "old_revised": 1.81,
   "old_unrevised": 2.2,
   "new_revised": 1.35,
   "new_unrevised": 1.57,
   "control_revised": 65.46,
   "control_unrevised": 67.91
  },
  "2017": {
   "n_revised": 693,
   "n_unrevised": 114082,
   "pct_revised": 0.6,
   "old_revised": 2.74,
   "old_unrevised": 2.56,
   "new_revised": 1.3,
   "new_unrevised": 1.55,
   "control_revised": 66.81,
   "control_unrevised": 69.27
  },
  "2018": {
   "n_revised": 1199,
   "n_unrevised": 130133,
   "pct_revised": 0.91,
   "old_revised": 2.0,
   "old_unrevised": 3.07,
   "new_revised": 1.92,
   "new_unrevised": 1.63,
   "control_revised": 62.3,
   "control_unrevised": 70.42
  },
  "2019": {
   "n_revised": 2278,
   "n_unrevised": 143975,
   "pct_revised": 1.56,
   "old_revised": 2.68,
   "old_unrevised": 3.56,
   "new_revised": 2.55,
   "new_unrevised": 1.77,
   "control_revised": 67.82,
   "control_unrevised": 71.71
  },
  "2020": {
   "n_revised": 4900,
   "n_unrevised": 163587,
   "pct_revised": 2.91,
   "old_revised": 3.39,
   "old_unrevised": 4.03,
   "new_revised": 1.98,
   "new_unrevised": 1.82,
   "control_revised": 70.88,
   "control_unrevised": 72.92
  },
  "2021": {
   "n_revised": 12351,
   "n_unrevised": 159962,
   "pct_revised": 7.17,
   "old_revised": 4.05,
   "old_unrevised": 4.62,
   "new_revised": 2.05,
   "new_unrevised": 1.93,
   "control_revised": 72.85,
   "control_unrevised": 73.67
  },
  "2022": {
   "n_revised": 39183,
   "n_unrevised": 136958,
   "pct_revised": 22.25,
   "old_revised": 4.63,
   "old_unrevised": 5.11,
   "new_revised": 2.38,
   "new_unrevised": 1.97,
   "control_revised": 74.12,
   "control_unrevised": 74.03
  },
  "BASE": {
   "n_revised": 56434,
   "n_unrevised": 446418,
   "pct_revised": 11.22,
   "old_revised": 4.39,
   "old_unrevised": 4.54,
   "new_revised": 2.27,
   "new_unrevised": 1.9,
   "control_revised": 73.56,
   "control_unrevised": 73.48
  }
 },
 "labels": {
  "agreement": "343/351",
  "cohen_kappa": 0.892
 },
 "pilot": {
  "source": "Firecrawl Research Index, 38 arXiv categories x 3 topics x 2015-2026",
  "abstracts": 41657
 }
}